Spotlight Song: “Eldest Daughter” by Taylor Swift
October 20th, 2025
Welcome to our Spotlight Song!
Each week, Musicians Found shines a light on a new song that we’re sure you’ll enjoy. With a mix of emerging and established musicians, you might just find your new favourite artist.
Are you a musician with a song you’d like us to feature? Apply here.
Taylor Swift’s The Life of a Showgirl Takes Us Behind the Scenes of a Superstar Life
Every Taylor Swift album has a heart-wrenching Track 5, and The Life of a Showgirl’s “Eldest Daughter” might fittingly be her most misunderstood.
In just over four minutes, Taylor explores facets of the eldest daughter experience through a lyrical, piano-led ballad.
While the song has had a mixed reception, with many fans balking at the internet slang peppered throughout the lyrics, the beautiful instrumentation and signature Swift-style bridge make it a relatable and enjoyable listen.
Taylor Swift’s “Eldest Daughter” Tackles the Impact of Internet Culture
“Eldest Daughter” opens with a simple melody floating over dissonant piano chords.
Taylor takes a deep breath before starting to sing, her soft voice bringing an added layer of vulnerability to her already honest lyrics.
The first verse explores today’s internet culture, which is often fast-paced and relentless.
While the discourse around internet culture has certainly picked up with the advancement of social media, scouring the internet for brutal answers to our questions has always been part of the eldest daughter experience.
Eldest daughters don’t have someone else to look up to. We learn to fit in through a trial by fire. We don’t always have someone to act as our guide, so we figure things out for ourselves.
Today’s eldest daughters might scroll through TikTok, seeking answers from their “internet big sisters.” A decade ago, we scoured magazines and YouTube tutorials, trying to find some sort of blueprint to build ourselves up from.
The internet has become our phantom guide, and Swift’s lyrics highlight just how cruel and unforgiving it can be to follow.
Moving into the pre-chorus, Taylor sings about a “terminal uniqueness” that many eldest daughters suffer from. We try to build up an outer appearance of someone cool and collected, someone who is independent and in control.
We like to frame our independence as a choice, rather than the necessity it often is.
“Eldest Daughter” Explores the Beauty and Bravery in Vulnerability
Yet as Taylor brings us into the first chorus of the song, she admits that she may not be as untouchable as she seems.
The chorus fills out the piano chords with synthesized notes echoing in the background, and suddenly the solitary melody doesn’t feel so lonely.
Her lyrics mirror this change, exploring the idea that while there may still be people waiting to betray her and areas of her life where she needs to keep her guard up, this relationship may be a safe place to finally let go.
The second verse brings in a bright guitar that fills out the background of the song, adding another layer of support to lift the melody.
Taylor’s lyrics explore the idea that eldest daughters aren’t born tough – they learn to be tough out of necessity.
Through broken bones and broken hearts, eldest daughters learn to be cautious. We learn not to want the things we aren’t sure we can have. We learn to pretend we never wanted them in the first place.
But as the song continues, we realize our deepest desires might not be so unattainable after all. Maybe the lies we tell ourselves don’t keep us safe – they simply keep us alone.
The “Eldest Daughter” Bridge is the Song’s Highlight
Taylor Swift is known for her iconic bridges, and “Eldest Daughter’s” bridge might be its best moment.
Singing of life’s simple, beautiful pleasures, Swift paints a picture of mundane bliss, admitting that all the things she said she never wanted were really things she feared she couldn’t have.
The bright instrumentation highlights the kind of happiness you have as a kid – before the world tries to teach you it’s impossible to keep.
The background instrumentals fade as Swift softly concludes the bridge with the line, “Every youngest child felt they were raised up in the wild but now you’re home,” a nod to the life she’s build with her fiancé, Travis Kelce (a youngest son).
Subtle Lyric Changes Shape the Narrative of “Eldest Daughter”
For the song’s last chorus, Taylor changes her lyrics, “But I’m not the baddest” to “Cuz I’m not the baddest.” This subtle change shows how she is loved because of her vulnerability, not despite it. While the first two choruses are determined, this last one is self-assured. She’s secure in the happiness she’s built, and she’s not going to let it slip away.
While “Eldest Daughter” may not be the song everyone expected when Swift dropped the track list, its sweet vulnerability makes it an instant classic among Swift’s emotional Track 5 ballads, reminding listeners that sometimes the greatest strength lies in allowing yourself to surrender.
Continue Reading:
Musicians Featured: Scott Helman on Music, Connection, and the Power of Sharing Our Voices
Spotlight Song: “Let Me Be Wrong” by Jensen McRae
